Can you outpick Chuck?

Make yes-or-no picks on TGL and WTGL golf. Beat Chuck by getting more picks right than he does.

Browse golf challenges
Ten ugly golf clubs ranked by what they sold for, led by a $5,606 double-ended Arrow putter cover
Back to The Perfect Lie

Ten ugly golf clubs ranked by what they sold for, led by a $5,606 double-ended Arrow putter

A YouTube list from The Caddies Bag runs from a $30 Ram Zebra to a hickory-shafted Arrow putter that opened at $100 and drew 26 bids at The Golf Auction.

Share this article

  • If there's a strange old putter in your garage, The Caddies Bag says check the stamp before you toss it. In a video posted Nov. 15, the channel's host, a former caddie and bag-room manager in the Carolinas who goes by Hank, ranks 10 ugly clubs by what they actually brought. Most prices come from The Golf Auction, including the buyer's fee. A few are used-club store asking prices, and he flags those as asking, not selling.

  • YouTube

    The Caddies Bag: 10 Ugly Golf Clubs Secretly Worth a Fortune (You Might Own One)

    Read source
  • He boils it down to three things that separate junk from a jackpot: age, how few survived, and a stamp that proves it's real. All figures below are as reported in the video unless noted.

    10. Ram Zebra putter, about $25 to $35

    The striped face-balanced mallet from the 1970s or '80s is here as a warning. One value guide puts it at $25 to $35, and Hank says he couldn't find sold listings behind that. Odd isn't the same as valuable.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Golf Chuck
  • 9. Odyssey White Hot 2-Ball, about $84 to $140 asking

    Paul Lawrie won the 2001 Dunhill Links with it, according to the video, and the public got it in January 2002. Second Swing had 84 of the originals listed at those asking prices, which tells you they're not scarce.

    8. Acushnet Bulls Eye, about $80 to $142

    Plain blade, lots of tour use. A Steve Jones practice putter sold for about $80 in January 2017, and a used Curtis Strange putter brought about $142 in November 2022.

    7. Schenectady putter, about $100 to $125

    Arthur Knight built it in 1902, and Walter Travis used one to win the 1904 British Amateur. Look for the "PAT MAR 24 1903" stamp. Recent results ran $101.58 and $124.28, and several went unsold at a $100 minimum.

  • 6. Nike Sasquatch SUMO2 square driver, about $150 to $300 asking

    The 460cc square head from 2007. Second Swing listings asked from about $150 to about $300, and Hank couldn't find sold prices.

    5. Hackbarth forked-hosel putter, about $165 to $260

    The shaft sits in the middle, held by a fork. Four results from 2019 to 2025 ranged from $164.91 to $260.85.

    4. A. Mills chipper-putter, about $626

    A two-way, center-shafted club from around 1904 out of the Jeff Ellis collection. It sold once, in November 2019, so Hank says to treat that number loosely.

    3. Early Ping, Redwood City stamp, about $1,434 to $3,455

    This is where the stamp really matters. A later 1A stamped Phoenix sold for about $201 in September 2024. Putters stamped "Ping by Karsten, Redwood City, Calif, Pat Pend" brought about $1,434 to about $3,455, and an AX model sold for about $3,078. The $3,455 one had its original leather grip.

    2. Gouick Perfect putter, about $4,300

    A center-shafted putter from Dundee, Scotland, around 1904. The auction listing claims fewer than 10 of this version are known. It opened at $300 and closed June 22 for about $4,300 with the fee.

    1. The Arrow putter, $5,606.94

    A double-ended aluminum mallet with a hickory shaft, made by the Golf Shaft and Block Company of Memphis. The Golf Auction's lot page confirms the details. It came from the Ralph H. Martin collection, had a $100 minimum, drew 26 bids and closed March 2 at $5,606.94 including the 19.5 percent buyer's premium. The house wrote that it had never handled one in 15 years.

  • What to do with yours

    Hank's advice: don't clean an old patent-stamped club, photograph the stamps first and compare them before selling. A Redwood City Ping goes somewhere safe. A Zebra, a Bulls Eye or a 2-Ball is a fine putter to keep using.