Can you outpick Chuck?

Make yes-or-no picks on TGL and WTGL golf. Beat Chuck by getting more picks right than he does.

Browse golf challenges
2nd Flight Golf plays Silvertip on GSPro and PurePlay and gives PurePlay the graphics and physics edge cover
Back to The Perfect Lie

2nd Flight Golf plays Silvertip on GSPro and PurePlay and gives PurePlay the graphics and physics edge

In a five-hole, same-course comparison, the sim creator ran GSPro 4.0 at Ultra 4K and PurePlay at 4K Epic, then credited GSPro's newest physics update.

Share this article

  • 2nd Flight Golf played the same five holes at Silvertip in GSPro and in PurePlay, and came away saying PurePlay looked better and played better. In a 21-minute comparison posted Nov. 16, the sim creator ran GSPro 4.0 and PurePlay back to back on the same course, gave PurePlay the edge on graphics and ball physics, and still praised GSPro's newest physics update.

  • How the test was set up

    The video opens with hole one on both platforms side by side. After that it plays the full five-hole stretch in GSPro, then the same holes in PurePlay. GSPro ran on its Ultra setting at 4K. PurePlay ran at 4K on Epic, and the creator said he might have to drop it to High. He said his PC has a 5070 Ti graphics card, so either setting should be fine.

    He says up front that he has no affiliation with GSPro or PurePlay and that the video is meant to help anyone trying to decide between them. He also figures most regular sim owners will probably end up with both.

  • Make your call with Beat Chuck

    Check the challenge board for the latest open games.

    All Beat Chuck games →
    Golf Chuck
  • What he saw

    Most of the runtime is gameplay with little commentary. The one note he makes during the PurePlay round is about the rough: the deep rough, and rough in general, is "way more penalized" in PurePlay, he says.

    His wrap-up is clear. On graphics, he says PurePlay was "obviously" better at Silvertip. He cautions that one course doesn't settle every matchup, and notes that GSPro's Silvertip has been out for some time. Still, if he had to rank them course to course on graphics, he thinks PurePlay would keep the edge, and he gives PurePlay the advantage on ball physics too.

    Credit to GSPro

    He saves a "big shout out" for GSPro. He says the new physics arrived in an update a few days before he recorded, and this was only his second time playing on it. His verdict: it is "definitely better." TPL wrote up GSPro's newest update on Nov. 15, when Triple Bogey Golf showed off virtual club throwing and Physics 2.0 fixes.

  • In the sim bay

    This is one creator's read on one course on one high-end PC, and he says he isn't trying to crown a winner. Silvertip works as a test because both platforms have it. PurePlay's version first showed up in flyovers before its early access opened. If you're choosing, start with the hole-one split screen at the top of the video, which is the quickest way to judge the graphics yourself. For a test built around shot data, Hosel Rocket fed the same Nova shots into GSPro and PurePlay at once.